We must prioritize sustainable procurement to meet climate targets

Do you know how the printer at your office was purchased, or the materials for the road you take to drive home, or what prompts your city or town to boast about its zero-carbon buses over its old fleet of gasoline buses? From 2022-23, per capita spending by federal, provincial, territorial and local governments combined was $24,225 per Canadian. Do citizens understand how much of this total $950-billion was spent in line with our values—from children’s education, to healthcare, roadworks, and more? The truth is, not very much. Certainly, not enough. Our modern industrial economy has historically focused our procurement practices on the “tyranny of the lowest price,” and in Canada, this rarely includes any sustainability criteria. On the occasions when we do include sustainability, the criteria are weak, and sustainability is often not considered in the scoring of the bid, or is weighted very low against other considerations. Frances Edmonds is the head of Sustainable Impact at HP Canada. Photograph courtesy of QUOI Media Group This sends a clear signal that the sustainability performance of both the supplier and the services or goods provided is unimportant. It’s time we prioritized sustainable procurement, and fast. Canada is significantly behind on its 2030 emissions reduction targets—an international commitment. According to the Climate Change Performance Index, Canada ranks 62nd in the world on climate action and energy transition behind Indonesia and Uzbekistan. While policies on energy transition are being debated, billions of dollars are allocated every day on products and services that could be helping us realize our low carbon future now. The government is not alone. Large multinational organizations have also avoided the urgent need to bring sustainability mandates into their day-to-day procurement activities. Total government and private investment on net-zero initiatives in Canada is roughly $25-billion, well short of the projected requirement of $140-billion per year. Sustainable procurement could have a profound impact on climate change mitigation and climate adaptation, and remains the simplest lever for all levels of government and blue-chip corporations to get right. Here’s how we can get there: First, by putting local communities first. The focus on lower prices has led to procurement being offshored, even for commoditized products. Energy, cement, steel, plastics and often chemicals can often be produced cheaply offshore, but producing them locally can help revitalize local communities, and build national expertise and pride. Small, immediate procurement signals are just as critical as large, long-term ones. Starting smart, articulating clear, complete, and unambiguous procurement mandates that progressively increase sustainable consumption from today to 2030 will create critical market signals to kickstart the mobilization towards a circular economy just as it did for renewables and biofuels. Apoorv Sinha is the founder and CEO of Carbon Upcycling Technologies. Photograph courtesy of QUOI Media Group The 2030 targets for procurement standards do not do enough, take too long to roll out, and fall into the middle management “valley of death.” Flexible procurement standards that allow adoption at small volumes can be instrumental in helping startups build sustainable business cases for large-scale adoption. Often procurement ships are so big that they can immediately overwhelm green product suppliers. For example, most hydrogen, fuel cell, CarbonTech, and green chemical suppliers are still extremely small in volumes they can deliver in the market. These volumes should still be absorbed quickly to encourage scale. World-changing tech solutions can start from anywhere—be it in a garage or a remote research lab—and innovators are now rightly celebrated for their resourcefulness. We need a similar view on creative and innovative procurement, championing it as an essential pathway toward sustainability. Public procurement needs to see itself as a market mover instead of as a price taker. We need to mandate that procurement consider many important factors, such as sustainable infrastructure, innovation, and long-term consequences—including best value—before taking initial price into account. Procurement has too often been a race to the bottom. Price matters, but it cannot be the first and only thing that does. A mandate of adopting new technologies in low-risk areas to accelerate the energy transition on five per cent of the budget would be both financially and practically feasible. One study found that even doubling the price paid for cement or concrete from a sustainable source would only impact total project costs by less than two per cent, with positive long-term sustainability outcomes. Our values shape who we are. If we are going to realize a net-zero future, we need to deeply consider what we value, and what it’s worth to us. We are faced with fundamental questions on how the world’s largest institutions view price and value, and the interplay between them. Let's empower our procurement professionals with organizational and societal backing to make the necessary changes, and to get on with tackling the wicked problems of our time through the power of sustainable procurement. Frances Edmonds is the head of Sustainable Impact at HP Canada. Apoorv Sinha is the founder and CEO of Carbon Upcycling Technologies based in Calgary, Alta. The Hill Times

We must prioritize sustainable procurement to meet climate targets

Our values shape who we are. If we are going to realize a net-zero future, we need to deeply consider what we value and what it’s worth to us.

Canada’s aging crisis and a call for reform in eldercare

Sudan’s warring sides and the long-simmering ethnic conflict

Balanced approach needed on right-to-repair bill, protecting IP rights and public safety

Reflections from a new citizen

Public Safety Canada’s dealing with natural and communication infrastructure disasters

As COP29 wraps up, will Canada finally stop funding fossils this fall?

Assessing Canada’s climate policy progress points to key sectors that need to step up

Sustainable Jobs Act must be strengthened if Canada is to succeed in a low-carbon future

Sustainable aviation fuels can help Canada meet its climate goals, but leadership is needed

Canada can still be a natural resource powerhouse in a net-zero economy

Humanity has reached a critical moment in history

News

Get free news updates

Opinion

Submit a guest opinion article

resources

Advertise

subscribe

get help

Get free news updates

Submit a guest opinion article

We must prioritize sustainable procurement to meet climate targets

Our values shape who we are. If we are going to realize a net-zero future, we need to deeply consider what we value and what it’s worth to us.

Get The Weekend Point of View Newsletter