It may be time to eschew tradition to beef up Canada’s military

OTTAWA—The Canadian Armed Forces are presently facing a personnel crisis, which threatens to hamstring the entire institution. Out of a combined regular force and reserve strength of 105,000, the CAF are currently short some 16,500 personnel. The problem is twofold in that the military is challenged to recruit sufficient numbers, while at the same time the CAF is having difficulty in retaining those already in uniform. As the overall numbers dwindle, it becomes that much more difficult to maintain the staffing of foreign commitments—like Canada’s forward-deployed battle group in Latvia—and simultaneously finding the necessary trainers to create the next generation of soldiers, sailors, and aircrew. Throw into this mix the constant interruption of training cycles to deploy military personnel to assist with climate-change-related natural disasters such as floods and fires, and it becomes readily apparent that Canada’s military is very close to the tipping point. Thus far, the solutions proposed by the senior leadership of the CAF have been little more than cosmetic tinkering to existing policies. In order to attract more recruits, the Canadian military has loosened restrictions on dress and deportment, radical hairstyles, facial hair, tattoos, and piercings. They are now allowed without restrictions and while service members still wear uniforms, they are no longer gender specific. It is also no longer necessary for recruits to be citizens of Canada. Applicants need only have their permanent residency. As for retention, the military hopes to make alterations to the pay and benefits package as an incentive to keep trained personnel in uniform. Vice-Admiral Angus Topshee, commander of the Royal Canadian Navy, has introduced the Naval Experience Program (NEP), which will allow recruits to join for a 12-month stint. After a short eight-week basic military training course, those personnel will be posted directly to CFB Halifax or CFB Esquimalt. They will not have any specific trade training so they will be considered “general duty” sailors for the duration of their year of service. Under the terms of the NEP, those sailors will serve on both coasts, earn $42,000, with free rations and quarters, and enjoy three weeks of leave. Topshee ambitiously hopes that after experiencing the Navy’s culture and seeing the world from the deck of a warship, 80 per cent of these general duty sailors will elect to extend their career and sign up for a second tour. Such measures, even if successful, may be a case of “too little, too late.” Given the developments on the battlefield in the ongoing war in Ukraine, maybe it’s time the CAF rethinks the structure of our military entirely. There is no question that the drone has emerged as the queen of the modern battlefield. Canada has correctly deemed it necessary to invest in a mixed future fleet of armed drones. However, the RCAF has warned that staffing such a new capability will be challenging due to the current staff shortage. Textron Systems' Aerosonde UAV at the CANSEC trade show in Ottawa on May 31. The Hill Times photograph by Andrew Meade As such, it is being proposed that reservists be activated to operate this future fleet of drones. Which begs the question: why do skilled drone operators need to be uniformed members of the military? As warfare increasingly becomes a high-tech contest between machines, drone pilots or operators don’t need to learn how to march in formation, polish boots, or be able to bench press their own body weight. They would not even have to learn field craft skills as, given the range of these new drones, they could be housed in comfortable lodgings well behind any front lines. There will always be a need for the traditional warrior, but perhaps it is time to look at those non-combat support trades to determine whether their role necessitates that they undergo full military training and be subject to the military justice system. While Topshee’s NEP will put general duty, non-trade-trained sailors aboard the Navy’s warships, maybe a parallel program could be implemented to hire specialized civilians to support the CAF without having to be in uniform. I know this will sound like blasphemy to the traditionalists who insist on maintaining the status quo, but desperate times call for desperate measures. As for the issue of the military being deployed to aid the civilian powers during natural disasters, one short-term solution would be to expand and support the group called Team Rubicon. Established in January 2010, this is an organization of CAF veterans who volunteer to assist in the aftermath of floods, fires, and earthquakes both at home and abroad. Expanding Team Rubicon and adding resources to increase their capacity would allow the military community to still reap the goodwill generated through aiding fellow Canadians, without having to strain our already over-tasked serving troops. Scott Taylor is the editor and publisher of Esprit de Corps magazine. The Hill Times

It may be time to eschew tradition to beef up Canada’s military

Given the developments on the battlefield in the ongoing war in Ukraine, maybe it’s time the CAF rethinks the structure of our military entirely.

Canada’s aging crisis and a call for reform in eldercare

Sudan’s warring sides and the long-simmering ethnic conflict

Balanced approach needed on right-to-repair bill, protecting IP rights and public safety

Reflections from a new citizen

Public Safety Canada’s dealing with natural and communication infrastructure disasters

As COP29 wraps up, will Canada finally stop funding fossils this fall?

Let’s mobilize our veterans

The Canadian Armed Forces’ disappearing act

Making the Canadian military fighting fit again

Tom Cruise isn’t going to save our skies

Throwing money at recruitment won’t fix the CAF’s personnel problems

News

Get free news updates

Opinion

Submit a guest opinion article

resources

Advertise

subscribe

get help

Get free news updates

Submit a guest opinion article

It may be time to eschew tradition to beef up Canada’s military

Given the developments on the battlefield in the ongoing war in Ukraine, maybe it’s time the CAF rethinks the structure of our military entirely.

Get The Weekend Point of View Newsletter