Hard to believe beard ban was a dealbreaker for military recruits

OTTAWA—It was announced last week that the Canadian Armed Forces are going to relax limitations on beards and allow more soldiers, sailors, and airmen to grow facial hair. Under the terms of the previous regulations, only sailors assigned to shore duty and infantrymen serving in specialized Pioneer engineering units were allowed to sport beards. There were also exceptions made for those whose religious faith forbids shaving, and in Afghanistan and Iraq beards were increasingly common among both Canadian special forces and regular troops. Of course, this being the military, there are still a number of rules defining what can and cannot be grown on one’s face. For instance, beards need to be neatly trimmed as opposed to having a full-on hipster look. A moustache must accompany the beard. And in circumstances where personnel are required to wear either firefighting gear or protective gas masks, the beards must be shaved off. All in all, it is a very minor adjustment to the existing policy, but what grabbed my attention was the official rationale for making this change. According to Chief Warrant Officer Alain Guimond, the CAF’s senior non-commissioned officer, the decision to allow beards is aimed at improving morale and attracting more recruits. I find it difficult to believe that a man considering joining the military would be prepared to conform to the strict discipline, meet the physical challenge, and be willing to die for his country, but draws the line at shaving off his beard. It is equally hard to envision that someone who has served in the military and is now prepared to transition to a civilian life would suddenly reverse course and stay in uniform just because they can now grow a set of whiskers. The military began sliding down the slippery slope of relaxed standards more than a decade ago when it removed even the most basic of fitness tests for new recruits. In order to not eliminate a candidate who might indeed one day make a professional service member, recruits were enrolled even though they were obese and unfit. They were put into what is essentially a weight-loss program to prepare them to begin basic training when and if they could get into shape. At the same time, the Canadian military became increasingly lax at enforcing the “universality of service” requirement of a minimum level of fitness for serving personnel. On Oct. 29, 2016, The Washington Post ran a story entitled “The battle of the bulge: many of Canada’s troops are fat,” in which it was reported that 49 per cent of all regular-force personnel were considered overweight and 25 per cent were considered obese. These statistics were taken from a survey conducted by the Canadian military. That survey concluded that the continued increase in obesity—6.1 per cent were considered morbidly obese—was a result of too much sitting around and bad eating habits. In other words, the obesity in the Canadian military is something easily remedied with fitness and self-discipline—two qualities one would expect military personnel to possess in abundance. However, instead of enforcing the policy of demanding that personnel keep themselves fit enough to be deployable, in 2016, 17.4 per cent of Canada’s soldiers were unable to meet that mark. The Canadian Armed Forces initiated a program to provide weight-loss surgery to the morbidly obese. It was estimated that DND spends more than $200,000 a year doing stomach-stapling operations on an average of a dozen soldiers. There is no corresponding evidence to suggest that the relaxing of fitness standards, or the accommodation of the excessively obese has in any way led to increased recruitment or any improvement in morale. The allowance of facial hair is a minor step, but it is a step. Now, with the legalization of marijuana, I fear that the future Canadian military will be overweight, dope-smoking, hairy-faced hipsters. For the record, I have long maintained that the Canadian military is not among the best in the world—it is the best in the world. Let’s hope it remains an institution all Canadians can take pride in. Scott Taylor is the editor and publisher of Esprit de Corps magazine. The Hill Times

Hard to believe beard ban was a dealbreaker for military recruits

The Canadian Armed Forces recently loosened limits on beards, citing the need to improve morale and attract more recruits.

Canada’s aging crisis and a call for reform in eldercare

Sudan’s warring sides and the long-simmering ethnic conflict

Balanced approach needed on right-to-repair bill, protecting IP rights and public safety

Reflections from a new citizen

Public Safety Canada’s dealing with natural and communication infrastructure disasters

As COP29 wraps up, will Canada finally stop funding fossils this fall?

Who will be Canada’s next chief of the defence staff?

Throwing money at recruitment won’t fix the CAF’s personnel problems

The Canadian military is in worse shape than the numbers indicate

The military fix not everyone wants to hear

Canada’s military closing out the year on a low note

News

Get free news updates

Opinion

Submit a guest opinion article

resources

Advertise

subscribe

get help

Get free news updates

Submit a guest opinion article

Hard to believe beard ban was a dealbreaker for military recruits

The Canadian Armed Forces recently loosened limits on beards, citing the need to improve morale and attract more recruits.

Get The Foreign Policy Newsletter